Welcome to Candlelight Inn, a charming chicken wings restaurant nestled in the heart of Scarsdale, NY. Known among locals, this delightful spot at 519 Central Park Ave is the go-to destination for flavor-packed wings and a warm atmosphere. If you’re searching for a cozy place where crispy meets succulent, your hunt is over.
As I stepped inside, I was immediately welcomed by the inviting aroma of fried chicken and the sizzle of wings hot off the grill. The intimate setting felt like a home away from home, where friendly faces and prompt service made me feel right at ease. It’s a small venue, which can make for a wait during peak hours, but the rewards of this popular spot are clearly worth it.
The wings here are undoubtedly the star of the show. I sampled the garlic parmesan wings, which were a perfect marriage of crunch and flavor. Each bite left my taste buds dancing, and I could easily see why they've garnered a loyal following. The buffalo wings also received rave reviews, with patrons expressing affection for their bold flavor and crisp exterior. For those looking for something a tad different, I recommend pairing your order with some addictive waffle fries that offer a playful twist on traditional sides.
Candlelight Inn isn't just about wings. Their menu boasts an enticing array of wraps, salads, and even burgers. The Chicken Caesar Wrap is a crowd-pleaser at $8.55, while the Steak Caesar Salad at $14.55 provides a hearty choice to satisfy those craving something lighter yet fulfilling.
The feedback from fellow diners echoes my sentiments. Patrons rave about the efficient yet genuinely friendly staff who ensure your dining experience is nothing short of delightful. One customer noted the wings as a favorite, while another praised the deliciously crispy onion rings accompanying their burger. Consistency seems to be a hallmark of Candlelight Inn, with excellent food and service repeatedly highlighted in customer reviews.
While the restaurant operates on a cash-only basis, the emphasis on excellent food and service makes it a minor inconvenience. And as you savor your meal, you’ll soon forget your wallet woes, reveling instead in a little gem that truly delights the senses. So, whether you are a local or just passing through, Candlelight Inn is worth a visit. The delicious food and warm atmosphere create a memory that is destined to linger long after the last bite. I certainly plan to return!
We’d love to hear from you! Your email address will remain private. Required fields are marked *
Nyelex
29/10/2025
Definitely a spot for the locals. Small restaurant with bar, lovely people. The staff were sweet, speedy service. The food was delicious, prices are reasonable. The wings are a favorite. The fries were crispy and fresh. Caesar salad was basic but still good. I will be going back.
Celeste C.
14/10/2025
Not being familiar with the area, I searched online for restaurants as I was starving, and this place popped up as a top option. Parking was convenient, and I was greeted and seated promptly. The staff was attentive and friendly throughout the visit. The food was outstanding! The wings were perfectly crispy on the outside and packed with flavor on the inside. The burger was cooked to perfection, and the onion rings were wonderfully crispy and flavorful. Highly recommend!
Taha M
08/10/2025
I highly recommend trying the garlic parm wings, which were cooked to perfection, accompanied by a side of cheese fries. We also tried their delicious burger which was made well done as asked. The food is generally good, and the restaurant hours are convenient. However, the only downside is the size of the location. It’s very small, and there’s always a wait to get a table.
Jacqueline San Jose
19/09/2025
The best buffalo wing restaurant in New York, I have been going here religiously for years and adore their wings and waffle fries. Highly recommend their drinks as well. Cash only!
Taneisha Tomlinson
09/09/2025
I enjoyed going to the Candlelight Inn. The food, service, and atmosphere were good. The servers were very kind and helpful. The place was cleaned and well maintained. The waffle fries are amazing. I highly recommend trying the waffle fries... They also have another section that does carry out, separate from the restaurant where we dined.
Perle75nyc
10/08/2025
Finally I tried this place and was satisfied!! The wings were perfectly fried. It was very light and crispy. Their hot and bourbon honey bbq sauces were perfect with crispy wings. I don’t have to go to Buffalo anymore! Taco salad was also great!! Cash only. p.s. A grandma sitting at the next table put her knife into ketchup bottle to dig ketchup and licked her knife. I’ve never seen and thought someone could do that in the restaurant. ============================= We always used to eat wings outside at this restaurant, but because of the sweltering weather, no one could sit out there, so for the first time, we sat inside. Looking out at the lush green trees through the window gave me a healing and peaceful moment. I loved the that spot.
Ashley Cortez
25/07/2025
This is one of my favorite places to go! Omg the broccoli poppers are a must when visiting 10/10 thank me later. Love my waffle fries with cheese and the garlic bread with cheese & pep! Mild wings are the best and I don’t like spicy! They are not as spicy as well.